History · 6 min read
How Researchers Linked the 1257 Eruption to Samalas Volcano
How geology, ash chemistry, ice cores, and a Lombok chronicle converged on Samalas while limiting claims about later crises.

How Researchers Linked the 1257 Eruption to Samalas Volcano
Ice cores from Greenland and Antarctica contain a large sulfate deposit dating to the late 1250s. For decades, researchers knew that a major explosive eruption must have injected sulfur into the stratosphere, but no securely identified volcano matched the signal. The source was linked in 2013 to Samalas, part of the Rinjani volcanic complex on Lombok in Indonesia, by combining field geology, radiocarbon dates, ash chemistry, and a local chronicle.
The convergence makes the source identification strong. It does not turn every cold season, harvest failure, or political crisis after 1257 into an effect of Samalas. Climate records show severe but geographically uneven disturbance, while historical archives show that some crises began before the eruption.
The volcanic signal appeared before its source
Large explosive eruptions can loft sulfur gases into the stratosphere. Chemical reactions form sulfate aerosols that scatter sunlight and alter Earth's radiative balance. Snow preserves some deposited sulfate; as layers accumulate and compress into ice, drilled cores become chronological archives. Peaks found in cores from both polar regions indicate an eruption whose plume reached a broad circulation system, although sulfate alone does not identify a volcano.
Dating an ice layer is not equivalent to reading a printed year. Researchers count annual layers and use reference horizons such as known eruptions, radionuclide events, and synchronized chemical signals. Older ice-core chronologies have been revised as those anchors improved. The large medieval sulfate event was long placed around 1258 or 1259 because deposition follows eruption and because dating carried uncertainty.
Tree rings supplied another clue. Trees in temperature-limited environments can form unusually narrow rings or frost-damaged cells after abrupt summer cooling. Networks showed growth anomalies around 1258 and 1259 in parts of the Northern Hemisphere. Medieval descriptions reported unusual weather. Together, the evidence implied a sulfur-rich eruption in 1257, but several candidate volcanoes lacked the required date, scale, or geochemical match.
Deposits and a chronicle converged on Lombok
Franck Lavigne and an international team investigated the large Segara Anak caldera within the Rinjani complex. Around it lay thick deposits from an eruption sequence: pumice fallout, pyroclastic density-current deposits, and material indicating collapse of the former Samalas edifice. Stratigraphic mapping let the researchers reconstruct an eruption of exceptional magnitude rather than a small local event.
Charcoal buried in the deposits provided radiocarbon constraints. The calibrated dates were compatible with the thirteenth century. They did not by themselves specify 1257, because radiocarbon ages produce probability ranges and wood can predate the eruption. Chronology strengthened when the geology was read beside the Babad Lombok, a text preserved in later manuscripts that describes the collapse of Mount Samalas, destructive flows, and damage to settlements.
The chronicle is not a contemporaneous instrument record. Its surviving versions, genre, transmission, and place names require historical interpretation. It nonetheless supplies an independent regional memory of a caldera-forming event. Archaeological evidence from Lombok, including remains buried by eruption deposits, is consistent with major settlement destruction, but the extent and demographic outcome remain active research questions.
Lavigne and colleagues estimated an eruption column reaching roughly 43 kilometers and more than 40 cubic kilometers of dense-rock-equivalent magma expelled, placing the event at magnitude 7. Numerical estimates depend on deposit preservation, thickness interpolation, and density assumptions. The exact values can change without overturning the central finding that the eruption was large enough to produce hemispheric effects.
Chemistry linked the volcano to polar ice
The load-bearing connection is geochemical. Explosive eruptions fragment magma into glass shards whose major-element composition reflects the source magma. Researchers compared glass from Samalas pumice with microscopic volcanic glass associated with the polar ice signal. The compositions matched within the analytical resolution reported in the 2013 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences paper.
No single chemical plot carries the argument. A persuasive tephra correlation requires compatible age, glass composition, eruption scale, and dispersal. Common magma types can resemble one another, and laboratory methods can introduce offsets. The team explicitly noted limitations of geochemical correlations. In this case, the stratigraphic and documentary evidence independently point to a 1257 event at the same volcano, while bipolar sulfate establishes a sulfur-rich eruption of global reach.
Later work refined the sulfur estimate and ice-core timing. Sébastien Guillet and colleagues combined ice cores, tree-ring temperature reconstructions, and historical sources in a 2017 Nature Geoscience analysis. Their chronology treated the eruption as occurring in 1257, with climate responses visible in 1258 and 1259. Continued revisions to ice chronologies can adjust deposition dates, but they have reinforced rather than displaced the Samalas attribution.
Climate effects were strong but uneven
Volcanic aerosols tend to cool the surface globally for a limited period, but regional weather does not respond uniformly. Circulation changes, ocean conditions, season, and internal variability redistribute the effect. Guillet's team found that 1258 and 1259 ranked among the coldest Northern Hemisphere summers of the past millennium in their reconstruction. Western Europe, Siberia, and Japan showed pronounced cooling, while Alaska and northern Canada were relatively warm.
Different proxies also respond differently. Tree growth reflects temperature, moisture, sunlight, ecology, and biological persistence. A ring network weighted toward high latitudes cannot simply provide a global average. Historical texts are geographically selective and describe socially salient extremes rather than standardized daily conditions. Climate models may simulate stronger or longer mean cooling than tree-ring reconstructions show, a mismatch affected by aerosol representation and proxy sensitivity.
Claims about famine require a separate causal chain. English and Japanese sources record serious food crises near the event. The 2017 synthesis concluded that these crises began before the eruption and that Samalas aggravated existing conditions rather than initiated them. Crop failure, storage, prices, conflict, institutions, and disease mediate the path from weather to mortality. A coincident burial horizon cannot on its own assign deaths to volcanic cooling.
The eruption has sometimes been presented as the trigger for the Little Ice Age. That label covers regionally varied cooling over centuries, not one globally synchronous start date. Samalas contributed a strong short-term forcing, and the thirteenth century contained other eruptions. Ocean-atmosphere feedbacks may extend some effects. Current evidence does not support treating one 1257 event as a sufficient explanation for all later cooling.
What the identification does not establish
The source case is cumulative and unusually strong: a magnitude-7 caldera eruption on Lombok, radiocarbon-compatible deposits, a regional account, and volcanic glass matching material tied to a bipolar sulfate peak. These independent lines explain why Samalas replaced an unnamed mystery eruption in scientific chronologies.
The consequences are less uniform than the source. Proxy networks establish major cooling in many regions after 1257, but also warm exceptions and uncertainty in magnitude. Archives indicate that eruption-related weather interacted with societies already under strain. The boundary of knowledge is therefore clear. Researchers can attribute the late-1250s sulfate signal to Samalas with high confidence; they cannot attribute every subsequent environmental or human event to that eruption alone.
Sources
4 sources, every one with a link you can follow.
- Lavigne et al., “Source of the Great A.D. 1257 Mystery Eruption Unveiled, Samalas Volcano, Rinjani Volcanic Complex, Indonesia,” PNAS 110 (2013), doi:10.1073/pnas.1307520110.
- Guillet et al., “Climate Response to the Samalas Volcanic Eruption in 1257 Revealed by Proxy Records,” Nature Geoscience 10 (2017), doi:10.1038/ngeo2875.
- Vidal et al., “The 1257 Samalas Eruption: The Single Greatest Stratospheric Gas Release of the Common Era,” Scientific Reports 6 (2016), doi:10.1038/srep34868.
- Sigl et al., “Timing and Climate Forcing of Volcanic Eruptions for the Past 2,500 Years,” Nature 523 (2015), doi:10.1038/nature14565.
