n.Newfeed

Art · 6 min read

What Conservation Revealed Beneath Later Paint on the Ghent Altarpiece

What imaging and conservation found beneath sixteenth-century overpaint, including the original Lamb and remaining attribution limits.

What Conservation Revealed Beneath Later Paint on the Ghent Altarpiece

When conservators began treating the Ghent Altarpiece in 2012, much of what viewers saw was not the surface completed in 1432. Large areas had been covered by later paint, most of it associated with a sixteenth-century intervention. Removing varnish and overpaint exposed sharper spatial effects, detailed fabrics and architecture, and the original face of the central Lamb.

The project did not return the polyptych to a perfectly recoverable first day. Paint had aged, panels had moved, parts were lost, and some changes could not be assigned confidently to the Van Eycks or a later hand. Its importance lies in how imaging, microscopic study, documents, and conservation tests made those layers distinguishable enough for bounded decisions.

A 1432 work with a long material history

The multi-panel work known as The Adoration of the Mystic Lamb was made for the church now called Saint Bavo's Cathedral in Ghent. An inscription on the frame says Hubert van Eyck began it and Jan van Eyck completed it; it was presented in 1432. Technical and archival research has strengthened the authenticity of that inscription, but the division of labor between the brothers remains an area of study.

The altarpiece opens and closes. Its exterior shows an Annunciation and donors; the interior presents an expansive sacred assembly centered on the Lamb. It was handled, moved, cleaned, altered, divided, stolen in part, recovered, and conserved across centuries. One lower panel, the Just Judges, has been missing since a 1934 theft and is represented by a twentieth-century copy.

Old paintings do not consist of an untouched image under removable dirt. The layer sequence can include original ground and paint, old fills, varnishes, retouching, and broad overpaint. Some later additions protect damaged material or have acquired historical significance. Solvents safe for one layer can affect another. “Reveal the original” is thus a research conclusion and an ethical choice, not a routine cleaning instruction.

Imaging separated original paint from overpaint

The Royal Institute for Cultural Heritage in Belgium, known as KIK-IRPA, organized the campaign in phases. The closed exterior was treated from 2012 to 2016; the lower register of the open altarpiece followed from 2016 to 2020; work on the upper register began in 2023. Treatment took place behind glass at the Museum of Fine Arts Ghent, allowing the process to be observed while the panels remained under controlled conditions.

Conservators first examined paint under magnification and made small cleaning tests. Infrared reflectography can reveal carbon-rich underdrawing beneath some paint. X-radiography responds strongly to heavy elements and panel structure. Macroscopic X-ray fluorescence scanning maps elements such as lead, mercury, copper, and iron across the surface. Infrared reflectance imaging spectroscopy distinguishes materials by how their spectra vary with wavelength.

No map directly labels “Van Eyck” and “later restorer.” Interpretation comes from the combination. An elemental distribution can trace a hidden form, but the same element may occur in several pigments and periods. Cross-sections from tiny samples show layer order and composition at one point. Crack patterns, brushwork, fluorescence, historical recipes, and correspondence across adjacent passages provide further evidence.

On the exterior panels, the team concluded that roughly 70 percent of the painted surface was covered by overpaint, mainly from the sixteenth century. This scale had escaped earlier detection partly because the later paint was skillful, followed original forms, and shared the surface's age cracks. Tests indicated that much of the fifteenth-century layer survived underneath in condition good enough to uncover.

Removal exposed the Van Eycks' working decisions

Removing later layers changed more than color saturation. The original paint created finer transitions of light, greater depth, and detailed textures. In the lower interior, overpaint had simplified buildings, vegetation, textiles, and the horizon. Its removal restored small descriptive elements and altered relationships between foreground and distance.

Technical images also document process. Underdrawing and changes show that composition developed during execution rather than being transferred without revision. The Van Eycks built optical effects with thin layers, opaque highlights, and control of light scattering. A 2020 study led by Geert Van der Snickt used X-ray fluorescence and infrared spectroscopy to reconstruct stages in painting the Lamb and distinguish multiple contours.

Such findings qualify a familiar claim that the brothers “invented oil painting.” Drying oils were used before them. Their achievement concerns highly refined handling, layering, and representational effects within an existing medium. Conservation provides material evidence for that practice without assigning them a technically isolated invention.

The treatment also changes attribution questions. Differences among passages may reflect two brothers, workshop participation, later damage, or conservation history. Once overpaint is recognized, scholars can compare original technique more reliably. Yet cleaning does not automatically identify which brother made a passage. Material sequence and authorship are related questions with different evidence.

The Lamb made conservation judgment visible

The central Lamb became the public emblem of the project because its uncovered face differs markedly from the later one. The original has frontal, widely spaced eyes and a more direct gaze; the sixteenth-century overpaint supplied a more conventional animal face and altered ears and muzzle. Imaging and layer examination showed the later face lying over preserved original paint. Conservators removed it according to the same criteria applied elsewhere, rather than designing a new expression.

One part remained unresolved. Imaging revealed an earlier squared enlargement of the Lamb's hindquarters made with lead-white paint. Researchers could not determine whether it was an adjustment by the original artist or a very early alteration by someone else. Because the attribution was uncertain, the team left that contour in place. The decision demonstrates that a restoration can expose one layer while retaining another when evidence differs.

The public response to the face also illustrates how familiarity can be mistaken for authenticity. Reproductions had normalized the overpainted Lamb. The newly visible face looked novel in 2020, although the evidence dated it to the original campaign. Conversely, age alone does not require removal: a later addition may be historically important or inseparable without damage. The project's international commission evaluated significance, condition, reversibility, and documentation rather than applying a rule that oldest is preferable.

Restoration recovers evidence within limits

The campaign established that broad sixteenth-century overpaint had concealed substantial surviving work by the Van Eycks. Multimodal imaging, samples, test windows, and close examination triangulated that conclusion. The treatment revealed material and compositional details that now alter formal analysis of the altarpiece.

What remains unknown includes the complete division of labor, the status of some early changes, and the original appearance of aged or lost materials. Retouching makes losses legible at viewing distance but is documented and designed to remain distinguishable under examination. Conservation cannot reverse five centuries. It can make an evidence-based choice among surviving layers, record that choice, and leave future researchers a clearer account of what was found and what was inferred.

Sources

4 sources, 1 of them with a link you can follow.

  1. Van der Snickt et al., “Dual Mode Standoff Imaging Spectroscopy Documents the Painting Process of the Lamb of God in the Ghent Altarpiece,” Science Advances 6 (2020), doi:10.1126/sciadv.abb3379.
  2. KIK-IRPA, The Ghent Altarpiece: Research and Conservation of the Interior, The Lower Register (2021) and campaign documentation.
  3. KIK-IRPA, “The Conservation Treatment of the Ghent Altarpiece” synthesis (2020).
  4. University of Antwerp AXIS project, phase reports on macroscopic X-ray fluorescence imaging of the altarpiece.

Want the reader to remember this spot? Sign in — it is free.

Next What Technical Imaging Reveals About Vermeer's Working Process

The app

Keep going, or take it with you.

Free accounts read twenty pieces a day. Pro is US$1.99 a month or US$11.99 a year for unlimited reading.