Literature · 6 min read
How Their Eyes Were Watching God Moved from Contested Reception to Canonical Status
How reviews, publishing, archival recovery, feminist criticism, and teaching reshaped the reception of Hurston's 1937 novel.

How Their Eyes Were Watching God Moved from Contested Reception to Canonical Status
Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God was published in 1937. It received serious attention, including praise and sharp criticism, then sold modestly and went out of print. By the late twentieth century it had become one of the most widely taught novels in the United States. This trajectory is sometimes compressed into a story of a masterpiece rejected by its era and rescued by later readers.
The record is more instructive. Contemporary reception was divided, not silent. Hurston’s reputation declined through interacting literary, political, commercial, and personal circumstances. Black women writers and scholars restored access to her work and supplied new critical questions. Canonization did not simply reveal a value that institutions had somehow failed to see; it changed through reprinting, teaching, archives, feminist criticism, and debate about vernacular voice and political representation.
A 1937 novel entered an active argument about Black writing
Hurston wrote much of the novel in Haiti in 1936 while conducting anthropological research. Published the following September, it follows Janie Crawford as she narrates her marriages, work, love, violence, and return to Eatonville, Florida. The framing conversation with her friend Pheoby encloses a narrative rich in Black Southern vernacular dialogue and a more conventionally literary third-person voice.
Reviewers did not agree about what that formal choice accomplished. In the October 1937 issue of New Masses, novelist Richard Wright argued that Hurston’s characters continued a minstrel tradition designed to satisfy white readers and that the novel lacked a serious theme. His review came from a leftist political and aesthetic commitment to literature confronting racial oppression directly. Alain Locke, writing in Opportunity, also wanted Hurston to move beyond what he regarded as charming folklore toward social document and motive.
Other reviewers praised the book. In the Journal of Negro History, Carter G. Woodson called it a gripping story and commended Hurston’s ability to write dialogue. The mainstream press carried favorable notices as well. The Library of Congress’s Hurston collections place the novel within her larger work as a folklorist, novelist, dramatist, and Federal Writers’ Project researcher.
The disagreement was not a simple contest between readers who recognized quality and those who did not. It concerned what Black literature should represent during segregation and economic crisis, how dialect functioned after minstrelsy, and whether attention to gender, intimacy, and a self-governing Black town evaded or reframed political life. Those questions remained central to later criticism, even when judgments changed.
Obscurity had more than one cause
The novel did not disappear immediately after hostile reviews. It remained in print for several years and Hurston published subsequent books. But her career weakened in the 1940s. Literary fashion shifted toward protest fiction and urban realism. Her politics and public statements alienated potential allies. Publishers let books lapse. Financial insecurity intensified, and she died in 1960 in a Florida welfare home.
A damaging 1948 arrest on a false allegation also affected her reputation and well-being, though the charge was dismissed and evidence showed she had been outside the country when the alleged event occurred. This episode should not be made the sole cause of her decline. Publishing markets, critical networks, gender, class, and ideological conflict were already operating.
Nor was Hurston wholly forgotten. Scholars, librarians, Black communities, relatives, and readers preserved books and records. Robert Hemenway began research that would become a major biography. The language of “rediscovery” can obscure those continuities, but it accurately describes a large change in institutional visibility and availability.
Reprinting and Black feminist criticism created new access
Alice Walker’s essay “Looking for Zora,” first published in Ms. in 1975 under the title “In Search of Zora Neale Hurston,” became a symbolic turning point. Walker described traveling to Florida, locating Hurston’s unmarked grave, and claiming a literary ancestry. The essay joined recovery to questions facing contemporary Black women writers: who counted as a predecessor, which experiences literary history had excluded, and how a living tradition could be reconstructed from incomplete public memory.
The University of Illinois Press reissued Their Eyes Were Watching God in 1978, with a foreword by Hemenway. Virago published it in Britain. Readily available editions allowed courses and critics to assign the same text rather than merely mention it. The Modern Language Association’s 1977 seminar on Black women writers and expanding Black studies and women’s studies programs supplied institutional settings for sustained interpretation.
Writers and scholars including Mary Helen Washington, Barbara Smith, June Jordan, Sherley Anne Williams, Cheryl Wall, and Henry Louis Gates Jr. did not all make the same argument. Some emphasized Janie’s movement toward voice and self-definition. Others examined the novel’s folk forms, signifying practices, narrative authority, sexuality, labor, or ambivalent treatment of race and gender. Criticism also asked whether the ending secures independence, romanticizes Tea Cake, or inadequately confronts his violence.
This plurality matters. Recovery did not replace a political reading with an apolitical celebration. It expanded what counted as political and aesthetic evidence while preserving disagreements about the book.
Canonical status was built through institutions
By the 1980s and 1990s, the novel appeared regularly in college and secondary-school curricula, anthologies, scholarly monographs, and conferences. Gates’s account of Hurston in The Signifying Monkey placed her within a theory of African American intertextuality. The Library of America included Hurston’s novels and stories in 1995. An Oprah Winfrey-produced television adaptation appeared in 2005. Each event brought different audiences and interpretive frames.
Canonization creates feedback. Teaching produces editions and study materials; availability makes teaching easier; scholarship generates new questions; adaptations broaden recognition. Sales then appear to confirm importance. This does not mean value is arbitrary. The novel’s formal complexity, historical specificity, humor, and account of Janie’s narrated life sustain repeated analysis. It means that durable attention requires material channels.
Those channels also simplify. Marketing can present Janie’s story as uncomplicated empowerment, detaching it from class, racial violence, the 1928 Okeechobee hurricane, and the novel’s difficult gender relations. A recovery narrative can portray all 1930s Black critics as shortsighted men, despite varied contemporary reviews and later criticism by Black women. Canonical praise can become another way not to read closely.
Textual history introduces further questions. Hurston’s use of vernacular has been defended as preserving expressive form and criticized as vulnerable to stereotype. Her anthropological practice supplied close knowledge of speech and folklore, but anthropology’s methods and power relations also require examination. The novel stages voice through written representation; it does not provide an unmediated recording of a community.
What the reception history supports
The established chronology is clear. Their Eyes Were Watching God received mixed reviews in 1937, later became difficult to obtain, returned through reprinting and the labor of writers and scholars, and reached canonical status through education and cultural institutions. Alice Walker’s intervention was crucial to the revival, but it worked within a broader recovery movement and depended on publishers, archives, teachers, and readers.
The contested questions concern evaluation. Was Wright’s demand for explicit protest too narrow, or did later celebrations understate racial and economic conflict? Does Janie achieve a voice, and who controls that voice in the narration? How should readers judge Tea Cake’s violence alongside the novel’s representation of love? No reception history can settle those interpretive disputes.
What it can show is that a canon is neither a neutral ranking nor a pure conspiracy. It is a maintained system of access and argument. Hurston’s novel endured because later readers found questions the earlier critical framework had discounted, and because institutions made the book physically and intellectually available. Its current standing should not end the debate that restored it.
Sources
4 sources, every one with a link you can follow.
- Library of Congress, Zora Neale Hurston collections and related resources.
- Richard Wright, 1937 review in New Masses, reprinted by the University of Virginia.
- Alice Walker, “Looking for Zora,” archival discussion at the National Endowment for the Humanities.
- Cheryl A. Wall, Women of the Harlem Renaissance, Indiana University Press.
